Understanding Executory Contracts in Real Estate

When dealing with real estate transactions, understanding contract types is crucial. Among the various types of contracts available, an executory contract may be one of the more subtle ones concerning real estate transactions. It is actually one of the most commonly used concerning land and real estate contracts, such as rent-to-own and installment land contracts. But what is an executory contract in real estate, and how is it different from the rest?

What is an executory contract in real estate?

An executory contract in real estate is an agreement in which both the buyer and the seller have remaining obligations that must be satisfied before property ownership is fully conveyed. As opposed to a fully executed contract, in which all terms and conditions of the contract have been met, an executory contract is considered “open” because of particular actions that are still pending, such as installment payments or property repairs.

For example, let’s say Jack wanted to buy a plot of land from Sue. They come to an agreement on a purchase price, but instead of paying it all at once, Jack has to make monthly payments with Sue until he pays the full balance. During this period, Sue still retains the legal title to the property, even though Jack has possession and equitable rights. Only when Jack completes all payments will the deed and ownership transfer to him.

Why are executory contracts used in real estate?

Executory contracts offer unique benefits to both parties involved, particularly in specific real estate transactions like installment land contracts or lease-to-own arrangements. Here’s why someone might choose an executory contract:

1. Flexibility for Buyers and Sellers: These contracts allow buyers who may not qualify for traditional financing to enter into a property agreement, and sellers can potentially earn a higher return through installment payments.
2. Equitable Ownership Without Full Legal Title: The buyer gains possession and some ownership rights without fully owning the property yet, while the seller still holds legal title until all conditions are met.
3. Risk Mitigation for Sellers: If a buyer defaults, the seller retains ownership of the property, potentially avoiding the lengthy and costly foreclosure process associated with traditional mortgages.

Common types of executory contracts in real estate

1. Real Estate Purchase Agreements: Typically used when a buyer agrees to purchase a property and pays the seller in installments until the full amount is settled. The buyer may move in during this time but does not get legal title until final payment.
2. Lease-to-Own Agreements: These contracts allow a tenant to rent a property with the option to purchase at a later date. The rent payments often go toward the purchase price, making this a type of executory contract where ownership transfer is conditional.
3. Installment Land Contracts: Similar to purchase agreements, but instead of a lump sum, the buyer pays the seller in installments. Only when all payments are complete does the seller convey the deed.

Example of an executory contract in real estate

Now, let’s demonstrate this by an example. Suppose Sam and Jenny enter into an installment land contract for a property. Sam is obliged to pay installments per month for 10 years, whereby, at the end of this period, he finishes paying the purchase price for the property. Throughout this period, or in other words, before the full payment of the purchase price, Jenny has the legal title to the house, while Sam is in possession and has a right to use it.

If Sam chooses to sell the property before paying for it in full, then he cannot sell without the consent of Jenny because she is still holding the legal title of the property. When all terms are met, then Jenny will transfer the title of the property to Sam, upon which the contract is said to have been fully executed.

Obligations under an executory contract

One of the defining features of an executory contract in real estate is the ongoing legal obligations for both parties involved. Here’s a breakdown of typical contractual obligations:

Buyer’s Obligations:

• Make regular installment payments.
• Maintain the property in good condition.
• Pay property taxes and insurance (if stipulated in the contract).
• Comply with any use restrictions outlined in the agreement.

Seller’s Obligations:

• Retain legal title until the contract is fully performed.
• Provide clear property disclosures.
• Transfer a general warranty deed upon fulfillment of the buyer’s obligations.
• Maintain property insurance until the buyer takes full ownership.

These shared responsibilities are what keep the contract executory until every requirement is met and they get to the contract execution.

Benefits of executory contracts for buyers and sellers

For buyers

1. Lower Initial Investment: Buyers can move into a property and pay for it over time, rather than securing a large mortgage upfront.
2. Flexible Terms: Often, sellers are more willing to negotiate payment schedules, down payments, and interest rates.
3. Opportunity to Build Equity: Buyers gain equitable title, which gives them the right to build equity before full ownership.

For sellers

1. Steady Cash Flow: Sellers receive consistent monthly payments, providing a stable income stream.
2. Protection Against Default: If the buyer defaults, the seller retains the property and can resell it.
3. Potential for Higher Returns: Interest and installment payments can generate a higher overall return compared to a traditional sale.

Risks involved with executory contracts

While executory contracts have benefits, they also come with certain risks, particularly for the buyer:

• No Immediate Title Transfer: The buyer doesn’t own the property until the contract is fully performed, making it difficult to use the property as collateral or to sell it.
• Loss of Investment: If the buyer defaults, they could lose all payments made up to that point without gaining ownership.
• Sellers Retain Control: Because legal title remains with the seller, they have greater control over the property during the executory period.

For sellers, there’s the risk of dealing with potential buyer defaults or facing legal issues if the terms of the contract aren’t clearly outlined and followed.

Executory vs. Executed contract: key differences

A common point of confusion in real estate is the distinction between executory and executed contracts in real estate. To quickly differentiate between these two contract types, here’s a brief comparison:

Executory Contract: An executory contract is an ongoing agreement where not all obligations have been fulfilled by one or both parties. In real estate, these contracts often involve installment land contracts or lease-to-own agreements, where the buyer does not yet fully own the property. Title transfer typically occurs only after all terms of the contract are satisfied, such as full payment or completion of specific conditions.

This type of contract carries more risk since the buyer doesn’t immediately gain ownership, leaving room for potential non-compliance or default. However, executory contracts also offer more flexibility, allowing parties to negotiate or adjust terms throughout the contract’s duration. The gradual fulfillment of obligations means both sides need to remain vigilant to ensure the contract is completed as planned.

Executed Contract: An executed contract, on the other hand, signifies that all parties have fulfilled their obligations, and the agreement is complete. In real estate, this includes finalized property sales, where the buyer has paid the agreed-upon amount and the seller has transferred the property’s title. With title transfer completed, there is minimal risk involved as all terms and conditions have been satisfied, leaving little room for disputes or non-compliance.

Executed contracts offer less flexibility since the terms have already been set and fulfilled, meaning no further negotiations or modifications can be made. This type of contract provides closure and legal finality to the transaction, with both parties now legally bound by the completed terms.

How to create an executory contract in real estate

If you’re looking to draft an executory contract, follow these steps to ensure clarity and legal compliance:

1. Identify the Parties: Clearly state who the buyer and seller are, including any representatives.
2. Detail the Property: Include a full description of the property, such as address, parcel number, and legal descriptions.
3. Set Payment Terms: Outline the purchase price, down payment, installment amounts, and interest rates.
4. Specify Obligations: List the duties for both parties, such as maintenance, insurance, and tax responsibilities.
5. Include a Default Clause: Define what happens if one party fails to meet their obligations.
6. State the Transfer Terms: Indicate when and how the title will transfer after fulfillment.
7. Legal Review: Have the contract reviewed by a real estate attorney to ensure compliance.

Final Thoughts

An executory contract in real estate is an agreement where there are still active duties and responsibilities by both the buyer and seller until the contract has been fully satisfied. Such contracts allow flexibility but also carry with them a special kind of risk and benefit. Be it a purchase agreement, lease-to-own deal, or installment sale, these terms and accompanying obligations have to be well realized. 

The biggest advantage to the buyers is equitable title and flexible payments, while for the sellers, it’s retention of legal control until full performance.

Preparing for a real estate licensing exam? Be sure to check out Lexawise’s comprehensive exam prep to get a deeper understanding and ace your licensing exam!

Check your understanding with a quick question

Q: Identify which of the following statements best describes the difference between an executed and executory contract.

• Executed contracts are written, while executory contracts are verbal.
• Executed contracts involve a transfer of property, while executory contracts do not.
• Executed contracts have been fully performed, while executory contracts have not yet been performed.(correct answer)
• Executed contracts are legally binding, while executory contracts are not.